The court, which is composed of 15 judges from as many countries, will now hear if Jadhav's rights were violated.
The Indian contention
India, represented by Senior Supreme Court lawyer Harish Salve, on Monday challenged Jadhav’s death sentence by invoking Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations which provides for consular access to foreign nationals.
Lok Sabha Elections#Elections With
- All
- Uttar Pradesh
- Maharashtra
- Tamil Nadu
- West Bengal
- Bihar
- Karnataka
- Andhra Pradesh
- Telangana
- Kerala
- Madhya Pradesh
- Rajasthan
- Delhi
- Other States
But what if Pakistan doesn’t comply with the ICJ’s orders? What are the limitations of the court and what is the way forward?
What if Pakistan doesn’t comply?
Article 94 of the United Nations Charter states that all the members of the United Nations have to comply with the ICJ decisions in the cases in which they are parties. Both the countries have signed and ratified this.
There is also an 'Optional Protocol' to the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations for the compulsory settlement of disputes. Both India and Pakistan are parties to this protocol too.
The court judgments in the contentious cases are final and without appeal, though there is no way ICJ can enforce its decisions. This is where United Nations Security Council comes in to picture. It can compel the states to follow the court’s ruling. But there are several problems with this method of enforcement.
First, a judgement against one of the five permanent council members or its ally countries can be vetoed by that member. This happened in the Republic of Nicaragua vs The United States of America where the court decided in favor of Nicaragua and awarded reparations to Nicaragua. The US refused to participate in the proceedings and also blocked enforcement of the judgment by the United Nations Security Council.
China, a member of the Security Council, can veto the Jadhav case order in favour of Pakistan.
Second, the Security Council can always refuse to intervene and then there is no way to enforce the judgement.
Third, a coercive measure by the Security Council can be adopted only if international peace and security are at stake. The Security Council has never done that so far.
Read More News on
Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.
Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online.
Read More News on
Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.
Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online.